| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| – | David Gatz | Ohio Wesleyan | 603 | – | ||
| – | Julian Beattie | Washington (Mo) | 599 | +2.3% | PB | |
| – | Dima Galkin | Washington (Mo) | 539 | -6.5% | ||
| – | Aaron Saule | Lindenwood | 519 | +5.9% | PB | |
| – | Nick Thornburg | Washington (Mo) | 498 | -0.2% | ||
| – | Scott Vennetis | Albion | 490 | – | ||
| – | J. D. Scott | Washington (Mo) | 462 | +1.4% | PB | |
| – | Thomas Gannon | Lindenwood | 444 | +2.6% | PB | |
| – | Zach McMunigal | Olivet | 424 | +1.2% | PB | |
| – | Thomas Ross | Lindenwood | 407 | – | ||
| – | Justin Chen | Washington (Mo) | 404 | -0.6% | ||
| – | Nathaniel Cook | Ohio Wesleyan | 389 | – | ||
| – | Matthew Marquette | Olivet | 388 | +6.2% | PB | |
| – | Mano Knowles | Hannibal-LaGrange College | 358 | – | ||
| – | Robert Calvert | Albion | 354 | +2.4% | PB | |
