| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| – | Kevin Fahey | Ohio Wesleyan | 548 | – | ||
| – | Rafe Maxwell | Olivet | 535 | +0.9% | PB | |
| – | Michael Conger | Olivet | 521 | -0.2% | ||
| – | Dima Galkin | Washington (Mo) | 505 | – | ||
| – | Gregor Becker | Lindenwood | 480 | – | ||
| – | Thomas Ross | Lindenwood | 477 | +2.2% | PB | |
| – | John Vanlishout | Washington (Mo) | 470 | +0.1% | PB | |
| – | Nick Thornburg | Washington (Mo) | 461 | – | ||
| – | Zach McMunigal | Olivet | 455 | – | ||
| – | Kellen Beckwith | Olivet | 439 | -1.7% | ||
| – | Zach Burgess | Olivet | 436 | -1.2% | ||
| – | Michael Sofia | Albion | 429 | +0.6% | PB | |
| – | Nick Dillon | Olivet | 420 | – | ||
| – | Christopher Potterton | Ohio Wesleyan | 413 | – | ||
| – | Ben Halperin | Washington (Mo) | 399 | -4.2% | ||
| – | Matthew Marquette | Olivet | 346 | – | ||
| – | Michael Gatz | Ohio Wesleyan | 329 | – | ||
| – | Mano Knowles | Hannibal-LaGrange College | 324 | – | ||
