| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| – | Michael Flanagan | Washington (Mo) | 595 | -0.8% | ||
| – | Rafe Maxwell | Olivet | 585 | +1.5% | PB | |
| – | David Gatz | Ohio Wesleyan | 483 | – | ||
| – | Nathan Eckersley | Ohio Wesleyan | 447 | – | ||
| – | Brian Johnson | Olivet | 438 | -0.7% | ||
| – | Nenad Pavikevik | Lindenwood | 414 | – | ||
| – | Jacob Lane | Albion | 413 | +5.7% | PB | |
| – | Zach Burgess | Olivet | 365 | +1.0% | PB | |
| – | Brian Fahey | Ohio Wesleyan | 230 | – | ||
