| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8:51.20 | Jan. 14, 2022 | Michael Brinegar | Louisville vs. Indiana |
| 8:56.32 | Oct. 30, 2021 | Michael Brinegar | Ohio State vs. Indiana vs. Penn State vs Virginia Tech |
| 8:59.65 | Jan. 17, 2019 | Michael Brinegar | Indiana vs. Michigan |
| 9:00.14 | Oct. 19, 2018 | Michael Brinegar | Texas vs. Florida vs. Indiana |
| 9:01.37 | Jan. 27, 2017 | Marwan ELKAMASH | Indiana vs. Louisville |
| 9:07.61 | Oct. 30, 2015 | Jack Miller | Indiana vs. Kentucky, North Carolina, Tennessee |
| 9:07.92 | Nov. 19, 2012 | Jimmy Barbiere | Indiana vs. Penn State, Virginia |
| 9:08.35 | Nov. 19, 2010 | Illya Larin | Virginia vs. Penn State, Indiana |
| 9:12.15 | Nov. 5, 2010 | Illya Larin | Indiana vs. Michigan, Texas |
| 9:18.53 | Oct. 22, 2010 | Illya Larin | Indiana vs. Northwestern |
| 9:20.34 | Jan. 29, 2010 | Illya Larin | Louisville vs. Indiana |
| 9:30.65 | Oct. 23, 2009 | Ryan Hinshaw | Northwestern vs. Indiana |
| 9:35.34 | Oct. 24, 2008 | Steffan Troxel | Northwestern @Indiana |
