| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:22.13 | Feb. 22, 2024 | Max Murray | Atlantic 10 Championships |
| 4:22.92 | Feb. 16, 2023 | Max Murray | Atlantic 10 Conference Championships |
| 4:23.90 | Feb. 21, 2013 | Vatslav Lets | Atlantic 10 Conference Championships |
| 4:24.74 | Feb. 23, 2012 | Vatslav Lets | Atlantic 10 Conference Championships |
| 4:31.94 | Feb. 24, 2011 | Ethan Rowan | Atlantic 10 Conference Championships |
| 4:36.26 | Feb. 18, 2010 | Ethan Rowan | Atlantic 10 Championships |
| 4:41.87 | Nov. 14, 2009 | Ethan Rowan | Cleveland State vs. Niagara, Valparaiso, St. Bonaventure |
| 4:42.95 | Nov. 7, 2009 | Ethan Rowan | La Salle vs. Duquesne, St. Bonaventure |
| 4:44.80 | Oct. 17, 2009 | Ethan Rowan | St. Bonaventure vs. Pittsburgh |
| 4:49.38 | Oct. 24, 2008 | Michael Dansa | St. Bonaventure @Pittsburgh |
