| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:52.86 | Feb. 18, 2023 | Logan Kelly | Horizon League Championships |
| 1:55.16 | Feb. 19, 2022 | Logan Kelly | Horizon League Championships |
| 1:57.49 | Nov. 20, 2021 | Logan Kelly | House of Championship |
| 1:58.32 | Feb. 18, 2017 | Jonathan Stoller | Summit League Championships |
| 1:58.61 | Feb. 20, 2016 | Jonathan Stoller | Summit League Championships |
| 2:00.73 | Nov. 22, 2015 | Jonathan Stoller | IUPUI House of Champions Invitational |
| 2:01.03 | Feb. 21, 2015 | Adam Ferguson | Summit League Championships |
| 2:01.78 | Feb. 22, 2014 | Adam Ferguson | Summit League Championships |
| 2:05.15 | Nov. 24, 2013 | Adam Ferguson | House of Champions Invitational |
| 2:05.23 | Feb. 23, 2013 | Adam Ferguson | Summit League Championships |
| 2:06.08 | Dec. 2, 2012 | Adam Ferguson | House of Champions Invite |
| 2:06.79 | Feb. 18, 2012 | Adam Ferguson | Summit League Championships |
| 2:09.54 | Jan. 20, 2011 | Adam Ferguson | IUPUI vs. Saint Louis, Xavier, Western Illinois |
| 2:12.26 | Feb. 22, 2009 | Craig Noakes | Summit League Championships - Day Three - Finals |
| 2:17.64 | Oct. 17, 2008 | Craig Noakes | Butler, Centre @ IUPUI |
