| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:48.55 | March 16, 2022 | Taryn Wisner | NCAA Division III Championship |
| 4:49.85 | Feb. 12, 2015 | Campbell Costley | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:50.41 | March 17, 2010 | Hilary Callen | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:51.18 | Feb. 11, 2010 | Hilary Callen | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:53.30 | March 18, 2009 | Hilary Callen | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:59.90 | March 8, 2007 | Laura Menard | NCAA Division III Womens Championships |
| 5:03.50 | March 9, 2006 | Katie Embry | NCAA Division III Womens Championships |
