| Name | Team | Time | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jimmy Ranallo | John Carroll | +3.9% | PB | ||
| 2 | Casey Davis | Ohio Northern | +4.0% | PB | ||
| 3 | Rob Brocious | Mount Union | +3.1% | PB | ||
| 4 | Jeff Zeleznik | Ohio Northern | +3.4% | PB | ||
| 5 | Matt Carlozzi | Mount Union | +3.9% | PB | ||
| 6 | Jeff Savage | Ohio Northern | +3.1% | PB | ||
| 7 | Eric Langley | Mount Union | +5.8% | SB | ||
| 8 | Nick Grady | John Carroll | +4.7% | SB | ||
| 9 | Coury Sicker | Baldwin-Wallace | +6.5% | PB | ||
| 10 | David Calcaterra | John Carroll | – | |||
| 11 | Kevin Piccirilli | Ohio Northern | +1.3% | PB | ||
| 12 | Josh Shell | Wilmington | – | PB | ||
| 13 | Nathan Brown | Baldwin-Wallace | 0.0% | |||
| 14 | Steven Ljubi | Mount Union | – | |||
