| Event | Time | Date | Name | Meet | History |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 Free | 19.92 | Nov. 14, 2025 | Caleb Fry | Keydet Invitational | |
| 100 Free | 44.11 | Nov. 16, 2025 | Caleb Fry | Keydet Invitational | |
| 200 Free | 1:38.93 | Nov. 21, 2024 | Gellert Szedlak | Gamecock Invitational | |
| 500 Free | 4:32.10 | Nov. 17, 2022 | Peter Gilbert | Kenyon Total Performance Invitational | |
| 1000 Free | 9:33.69 | Nov. 11, 2022 | Peter Gilbert | Carson-Newman vs. Milligan | |
| 1650 Free | 15:51.60 | Nov. 19, 2022 | Peter Gilbert | Kenyon Total Performance Invitational | |
| 50 Back | 22.73 | March 5, 2025 | Paxton Smith | NAIA National Championships | |
| 100 Back | 48.98 | March 7, 2025 | Joash Mckonie | NAIA National Championships | |
| 200 Back | 1:47.09 | March 5, 2022 | Stephen Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 50 Breast | 26.94 | Oct. 14, 2023 | Caleb Fry | Union (KY) vs. Milligan | |
| 100 Breast | 53.56 | March 8, 2024 | Caleb Fry | NAIA National Championships | |
| 200 Breast | 1:58.65 | Nov. 16, 2025 | Caleb Fry | Keydet Invitational | |
| 50 Fly | 22.25 | Nov. 17, 2022 | Ethan McCosh | Kenyon Total Performance Invitational | |
| 100 Fly | 48.45 | March 7, 2025 | Joash Mckonie | NAIA National Championships | |
| 200 Fly | 1:49.01 | Feb. 11, 2023 | Stephen Gilbert | Appalachian Athletic Conference Championships | |
| 100 IM | 53.38 | Oct. 12, 2024 | Joash Mckonie | King Invite | |
| 200 IM | 1:48.09 | March 6, 2025 | Robert Adam | NAIA National Championships | |
| 400 IM | 3:51.08 | March 4, 2022 | Stephen Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 200 Free Relay | 1:19.82 | March 6, 2025 | Smith, Fry, Mckonie, Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 400 Free Relay | 2:58.97 | March 8, 2025 | Rinaldi, Smith, Fry, Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 800 Free Relay | 6:39.21 | March 5, 2025 | Adam, Szedlak, Bazzana, Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 200 Medley Relay | 1:27.42 | March 5, 2025 | Smith, Fry, Mckonie, Gilbert | NAIA National Championships | |
| 400 Medley Relay | 3:16.95 | March 8, 2024 | Smith, Fry, Trammell, Gilbert | NAIA National Championships |
