| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3:49.25 | Oct. 28, 2023 | Dickinson, Johnson, Peters, Ferguson | NYSPHSAA Section 3 Class B and C Championships |
| 3:52.62 | Oct. 21, 2023 | Dickinson, Johnson, Peters, Ferguson | Frontier League Swimming Championships |
| 3:53.37 | Nov. 1, 2022 | Ferguson, Dickinson, Weir, Peters | NYPHSAA Section 3 State Qualifier |
| 3:53.93 | Nov. 3, 2017 | Crossley, Kilburn, Way, Alvarado | NYSPHSAA Section III Championships - Class B |
| 3:58.25 | Nov. 6, 2015 | Alvarado, Medley, Way, Peters | NYSPHSAA Section III Championships - Class B |
| 3:59.52 | Nov. 7, 2014 | Alvarado, Olsen, Peters, Marilley | NYSPHSAA Section III Class B Championships |
