| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:57.97 | Feb. 16, 2025 | Ryan VanDeVeen | New Jersey Athletic Conference Championship |
| 1:58.21 | March 23, 2024 | Ryan VanDeVeen | NCAA Division III Championship |
| 1:58.76 | Feb. 18, 2024 | Ryan VanDeVeen | New Jersey Athletic Conference Championship |
| 1:59.18 | March 19, 2016 | James Shangle | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 2:00.44 | Feb. 21, 2016 | James Shangle | Metropolitan Championships |
| 2:00.66 | Feb. 16, 2014 | James Shangle | Metropolitan Championships |
| 2:01.36 | March 21, 2009 | Myles O'Connor | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 2:05.25 | Oct. 26, 2008 | Myles O'Connor | Stevens Tech @TCNJ |
| 2:05.75 | March 18, 2006 | Steve Swenson | NCAA Division III Mens Championships |
