| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:46.18 | Feb. 10, 2024 | Sean Killian | NYCHSAA State Championship |
| 1:47.72 | Feb. 7, 2024 | Sean Killian | All Catholic Meet |
| 1:48.28 | Feb. 11, 2023 | Sean Killian | CHSAA CITY CHAMPS |
| 1:49.30 | Feb. 1, 2023 | Sean Killian | All Catholic Meet |
| 1:51.37 | Feb. 8, 2022 | Sean Killian | Saint Joseph vs. Canisius vs. Saint Francis (Buffalo) |
| 1:51.78 | Feb. 10, 2014 | Yousuf Eltagouri | 14 New York Boys All Catholic Championships |
