| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3:57.32 | Oct. 25, 2023 | King, Defedericis, Lang, King | Section VI Girls Class C Championship |
| 3:59.98 | Nov. 4, 2022 | Erhardt, King, Defedericis, King | Section VI Girls Championships |
| 4:01.42 | Oct. 27, 2022 | Erhardt, King, Defedericis, King | Section VI Girls Class C Championship |
| 4:14.49 | Oct. 23, 2021 | Erhardt, Defedericis, King, King | ECIC Girls Division III Championship |
| 4:18.79 | Oct. 7, 2021 | Defedericis, Camp, King, King | Eden vs. Alden |
| 4:22.32 | Oct. 18, 2018 | Roy, Hillman, Jegierski, Warner | ECIC Class A Championship |
| 4:35.46 | Oct. 20, 2016 | Roy, Burke, Ritchie, Salim | Girls ECIC Class A Championshi |
