| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2:08.66 | Feb. 4, 2023 | Mike Allo | Great Northeast Athletic Conference Championship |
| 2:15.07 | Dec. 3, 2022 | Mike Allo | Connecticut Cup |
| 2:20.02 | Oct. 29, 2022 | Mike Allo | Norwich vs. USJ |
| 2:26.86 | Feb. 27, 2022 | Brandon Scacca | NEISDA Championships |
| 2:27.49 | Nov. 6, 2021 | Jake Wyse | Albertus vs. USJ-ELms-SJC |
| 2:28.36 | March 26, 2021 | Brandon Scacca | Albertus Magnus College vs University of Saint Joseph |
| 2:43.87 | Nov. 19, 2020 | Maksym Ugrak | CSCAA Virtual Cup - Round 6a |
| 2:44.25 | Feb. 2, 2020 | John Monroe | Great Northeast Athletic Conference Championship |
| 3:00.28 | Nov. 9, 2018 | Matt Gorman | St. Joseph (CT) vs. Elms, WCSU |
