| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:49.75 | Feb. 17, 2024 | Dalton Jobe | W&L Last Chance Meet |
| 1:50.11 | March 15, 2023 | Dalton Jobe | NCAA Division III Championship |
| 1:51.67 | March 5, 2021 | Danny Lynch | W&L Championship Time Trial |
| 1:52.28 | Feb. 15, 2019 | Danny Lynch | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 1:53.35 | Feb. 14, 2013 | Tyler Gehrs | Bluegrass Mountain Conference Championships |
| 1:53.91 | Feb. 16, 2012 | Christopher Washnock | Bluegrass Mountain Conference Championships |
| 1:54.93 | Feb. 17, 2011 | Robert Grattan | Bluegrass Mountain Conference Championships |
| 1:55.24 | Dec. 3, 2009 | Christopher Washnock | Virginia Invitational |
| 2:02.11 | Oct. 16, 2009 | Christopher Washnock | Washington & Lee vs Mary Washington |
