| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:31.29 | Feb. 9, 2023 | Dalton Jobe | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:32.91 | March 20, 2008 | Paul Crook | NCAA Division III Mens Championship |
| 4:38.28 | March 15, 2007 | Paul Crook | NCAA Division III Mens Championships |
| 4:38.61 | March 16, 2006 | Paul Crook | NCAA Division III Mens Championships |
