| Name | Team | Time | Score | Pts | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| X | Luke ERWEE |
 Queens (NC)
|
4:26.62 | D2-B | – | 798 | +1.1% | SB |
| X | Mohamed Hegazi |
Queens (NC)
|
4:27.78 | D2-B | – | 787 | +0.7% | SB |
| X | Alex Kunert |
Queens (NC)
|
4:30.55 | D2-B | – | 763 | – | |
| X | Balazs Berecz |
Queens (NC)
|
4:39.16 | – | 695 | – | ||
| 1 | Alex Ballard |
 Lenoir-Rhyne
|
4:48.93 | 9.00 | 627 | -2.6% | ||
| 2 | Samuel Murphy |
Lenoir-Rhyne
|
4:59.49 | 4.00 | 563 | -5.3% | ||
| 3 | John Carroll |
Lenoir-Rhyne
|
5:16.51 | 3.00 | 477 | – | PB | |
| 4 | Micah Grigg |
Lenoir-Rhyne
|
5:21.58 | – | 455 | – | ||