| Name | Team | Time | Score | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Thomas Staes | Seton Hall | 20 | |||
| 2 | Josh Tosoni | Seton Hall | 17 | PB | ||
| – | Jonathan Pollock | Princeton | – | |||
| 3 | Ricards Fortels | Rider | NICB | 16 | ||
| – | Daniel Arris | Princeton | – | |||
| 4 | Kyle Haflich | Seton Hall | 15 | |||
| – | Cameron Matthews | Princeton | – | |||
| 5 | Jonathan Bar-Eli | Seton Hall | 14 | |||
| – | Aaron Glas | Princeton | – | PB | ||
| – | John Ehling | Princeton | – | PB | ||
| – | Josh Kim | Princeton | NS | – | ||
