| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:56.24 | Feb. 14, 2024 | D'Angelo, Jones, O'Donnell, Hess | NYPHSAA Section IV Class C Championship |
| 1:57.56 | Feb. 9, 2019 | Bicalho, Cator Szymanski, Sinnott, Chapman | IAC Boys Championship |
| 2:01.39 | Feb. 14, 2018 | Dodici, Krebs, Sinnott, Kucerak | New York Section IV Class C Championships |
| 2:04.84 | Feb. 11, 2017 | Dodici, Krebs, Sinnott, Kucerak | IAC Championships |
| 2:06.59 | Feb. 17, 2016 | Welch, Krebs, Sinnott, Kucerak | Class C Sectionals |
| 2:13.67 | Feb. 11, 2015 | Sinnott, Krebs, Welch, Kucerak | 15 New York Section IV Class C Championships |
