| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5:35.74 | Feb. 18, 2025 | Chris D'Angelo | NYPHSAA Section IV Class C Championship (Boys) |
| 5:36.70 | Feb. 8, 2025 | Chris D'Angelo | IAC Championship (Boys) |
| 5:39.54 | Feb. 14, 2018 | Mark Dodici | New York Section IV Class C Championships |
| 6:22.89 | Feb. 11, 2017 | Elijiah Speight | IAC Championships |
| 6:57.51 | Feb. 17, 2016 | Mark Dodici | Class C Sectionals |
