| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Hain | 4:44.10 | Feb. 10, 2023 | Atlantic East Conference Championships |
| Collin Chartier | 4:46.37 | Feb. 21, 2014 | 2014 Capital Athletic Conference Championships |
| Matthew Essig | 4:46.90 | Dec. 6, 2013 | Randolph-Macon Invitational |
| Thomas Baroz | 4:57.56 | Feb. 18, 2011 | Capital Athletic Conference Inc. Championships |
| Rett Neiman | 5:10.94 | Feb. 12, 2010 | Capital Athletic Conference Championships |
| Thomas Baroz | 5:25.03 | Dec. 5, 2009 | Franklin & Marshall Invitational |
