| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:44.90 | March 19, 2025 | Natalie Garre | NCAA Division III Championship |
| 4:47.63 | Feb. 14, 2025 | Natalie Garre | NESCAC Womens Championships |
| 4:48.54 | Dec. 6, 2024 | Natalie Garre | Maine Collegiate Invitational |
| 4:56.78 | Nov. 23, 2024 | Natalie Garre | MIT vs. Bowdoin |
| 5:01.27 | Feb. 15, 2013 | Katherine Foley | New England Small College Athletic Conference Womens Championships |
| 5:05.80 | Feb. 17, 2012 | Katherine Foley | New England Small College Athletic Conference Womens Championships |
| 5:11.10 | Feb. 20, 2009 | Jennifer Beatty | Mid-American Conference Championships - Day Two - Finals |
| 5:39.20 | Jan. 20, 2006 | Katie YANKURA | ME Ground Hog International |
