| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:57.36 | Feb. 27, 2016 | Jeremiah O'Donnell | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:57.39 | Feb. 28, 2015 | Jeremiah O'Donnell | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:58.08 | Feb. 15, 2014 | Josh Zimmt | Cavalier Invitational |
| 1:58.93 | March 2, 2013 | Andrew Strait | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:00.22 | Feb. 25, 2012 | Andrew Strait | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:04.20 | Feb. 26, 2011 | Andrew Strait | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:05.71 | Feb. 5, 2011 | Andrew Strait | William & Mary vs. East Carolina |
| 2:07.60 | Feb. 27, 2010 | James Fenningham | Colonial Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:08.52 | Nov. 21, 2009 | James Fenningham | Terrapin Cup |
| 2:12.55 | Oct. 23, 2009 | Ben Ward | William & Mary vs. Mary Washington |
