| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9:21.53 | Oct. 22, 2022 | William Mullen | West Virginia vs. Cincinnati |
| 9:23.26 | Jan. 30, 2021 | William Mullen | West Virginia vs. Notre Dame |
| 9:27.32 | Jan. 14, 2021 | William Mullen | Pittsburgh vs. West Virginia |
| 9:27.67 | Oct. 27, 2017 | Tiki Saladin | West Virginia vs. Seton Hall, Xavier |
| 9:34.38 | Oct. 17, 2015 | Luca Fasulo | West Virginia vs. Virginia Tech |
| 9:34.52 | Nov. 7, 2008 | Justin Galbreath | West Virginia @Louisville |
| 9:43.93 | Oct. 11, 2008 | Justin Galbreath | Xavier, East Carolina, West Virginia @Marshall |
