| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:07.76 | Feb. 15, 2019 | Josh McCown | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:10.88 | Feb. 12, 2016 | Timmy Spichiger | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:11.91 | Feb. 19, 2010 | Alex Troxel | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:12.31 | Dec. 5, 2009 | Charlie Boehme | DePauw Invitational |
| 4:14.83 | March 19, 2009 | Charlie Boehme | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:23.19 | Nov. 18, 2006 | Brock Sishc | Wabash Invitational |
