| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3:50.89 | March 9, 2023 | Daniel Garcia | NCAA Division II Championship |
| 3:51.85 | Dec. 2, 2022 | Daniel Garcia | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 3:54.92 | Feb. 17, 2022 | Daniel Garcia | Great Midwest-Mountain East Conference Championship |
| 3:56.17 | April 1, 2021 | Daniel Garcia | GMAC & MEC Championship |
| 3:58.18 | Feb. 13, 2014 | Todo Djurovic | Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| 4:01.55 | Feb. 10, 2012 | David Soutoutl | Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:09.15 | Nov. 12, 2011 | David Soutoutl | Findlay vs. Urbana |
| 4:22.22 | Feb. 11, 2011 | David Conti | Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference Championships |
| 4:27.97 | Feb. 12, 2010 | David Conti | Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
