| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:24.25 | Feb. 15, 2024 | Nathan Rariden | Horizon League Championships |
| 4:25.94 | Nov. 17, 2017 | Ben Levart | House of Champions |
| 4:27.26 | Nov. 18, 2016 | Ben Levart | House of Champions Invitational |
| 4:29.57 | Nov. 20, 2015 | Ben Levart | IUPUI House of Champions Invitational |
| 4:29.61 | Nov. 21, 2014 | Tony Carroll | House of Champions Invitational |
| 4:30.83 | Feb. 21, 2013 | Tony Carroll | Summit League Championships |
| 4:39.41 | Nov. 30, 2012 | Tony Carroll | House of Champions Invite |
| 4:40.38 | Feb. 16, 2012 | John Van Dyke | Summit League Championships |
| 4:40.47 | Feb. 17, 2011 | Tyler McGowan | Summit League Championships |
| 4:46.07 | Nov. 12, 2010 | Tyler McGowan | House of Champions (IUPUI) Invitational |
| 4:49.86 | Oct. 17, 2008 | Tyler McGowan | Butler, Centre @ IUPUI |
