| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:37.45 | Feb. 14, 2024 | Nathan Rariden | Horizon League Championships |
| 1:37.52 | Feb. 13, 2019 | Jackson Sandala | Horizon League Championships |
| 1:37.71 | Feb. 23, 2018 | Jackson Sandala | Horizon League Championships |
| 1:38.18 | Nov. 22, 2014 | Lennart Kuester | House of Champions Invitational |
| 1:38.35 | Feb. 22, 2013 | Tony Carroll | Summit League Championships |
| 1:41.32 | Feb. 15, 2012 | Tony Carroll | Summit League Championships |
| 1:43.83 | Dec. 3, 2011 | Tony Carroll | Eastern Michigan Invitational |
| 1:44.41 | Oct. 28, 2011 | Tony Carroll | IUPUI vs. Butler, Centre |
| 1:45.19 | Feb. 18, 2011 | Lucas Green | Summit League Championships |
| 1:45.48 | Jan. 21, 2011 | Michael Steurer | IUPUI vs Saint Louis, Valparaiso |
| 1:47.01 | Feb. 21, 2009 | John Hudson | Summit League Championships - Day Two - Finals |
