| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| – | Justin Bronson | UMBC | 720 | +2.4% | PB | |
| – | Jason Mattingly | UMBC | 676 | +2.4% | PB | |
| – | Eric Jones | UMBC | 676 | +0.3% | PB | |
| – | Stanislav Sadovski | Seton Hall | 656 | +1.8% | PB | |
| – | Robert Anderson | UNC-Wilmington | 648 | – | ||
| – | Fred Deal | UMBC | 642 | +4.1% | SB | |
| – | Sven Schneider | UMBC | 633 | +7.4% | SB | |
| – | Aidan Akkari | UNC-Wilmington | 631 | – | ||
| – | Josh Nyce | Shippensburg | 628 | – | ||
| – | John Miller | Shippensburg | 626 | +2.9% | PB | |
| – | Zach Vonder Haar | UMBC | 623 | +3.4% | SB | |
| – | Gabe Oropollo | Shippensburg | 614 | – | ||
| – | Nate Ryan | Shippensburg | 613 | – | PB | |
| – | Ben Wolbert | UMBC | 607 | – | ||
| – | Seth Liston | UNC-Wilmington | 606 | -0.4% | ||
| – | Tucker Waldron | UNC-Wilmington | 604 | – | ||
| – | Robert Gokey | Georgetown | 601 | +3.2% | PB | |
| – | Patrick Hamill | Shippensburg | 597 | – | ||
| – | Evan Danz | UMBC | 591 | +2.1% | PB | |
| – | Dean McCain | UNC-Wilmington | 587 | +1.9% | PB | |
| – | Shawn Robbins | Shippensburg | 586 | – | ||
| – | Timothy Smullen | Shippensburg | 586 | – | ||
| – | Ben Clark | UNC-Wilmington | 582 | +0.3% | PB | |
| – | Alex Aguilar | UNC-Wilmington | 580 | +0.3% | PB | |
