| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Amirbek Usmanov |
 Maryville
|
1:51.13 | 672 | +3.3% | SB | |
| 2 | Joseph Park |
Maryville
|
1:58.14 | 560 | +5.0% | SB | |
| 3 | Karl Lindoff |
Maryville
|
1:58.36 | 556 | – | ||
| 4 | Justin King |
 Truman State
|
2:00.09 | 533 | -2.3% | ||
| 5 | Noah May |
Truman State
|
2:00.29 | 530 | +1.1% | SB | |
| 6 | Malcolm Hunter |
UMSL
|
2:02.20 | 506 | +1.9% | SB | |
| 7 | Patryk Golinski |
UMSL
|
2:03.11 | 494 | – | PB | |
| 8 | Michael Franz |
Truman State
|
2:04.27 | 481 | – | ||
| 9 | Ryan Dorsey |
UMSL
|
2:05.71 | 464 | -0.6% | ||