| Name | Team | Time | Imp | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Michael Boutwell | Washington & Jefferson | +7.8% | SB | |
| 2 | Alex Mathews | Grove City | +2.4% | SB | |
| 3 | Josh Kim | Grove City | +2.0% | SB | |
| 4 | Patrick O'Toole | Washington & Jefferson | – | ||
| X | Jared Bailey | Grove City | – | ||
| 5 | John Kelley | Penn State Behrend | +1.6% | PB | |
| 6 | Adam Walker | Grove City | +1.3% | PB | |
| 7 | Todd Slobodnyak | Westminster | +9.4% | PB | |
| X | Casey McDonald | Westminster | +2.2% | PB | |
| 8 | Erik Chesney | Westminster | +3.0% | PB | |
| X | Matt Green | Grove City | +6.6% | PB | |
| 9 | Adam Hodnichak | Saint Vincent | +1.1% | SB | |
| 10 | Kreighton Long | Saint Vincent | +0.1% | SB | |
| 11 | Jack Hudson | Frostburg State | +2.6% | PB | |
| 12 | Chase Saraiva | Westminster | +1.6% | PB | |
| 13 | Terrance Watterson | Penn State Behrend | +2.6% | SB | |
| 14 | Jacob DeVolder | Pittsburgh-Bradford | +4.9% | PB | |
| X | Daniel Henley | Grove City | +5.8% | PB | |
| 15 | Drew Shaffer | Pittsburgh-Bradford | +2.2% | SB | |
| X | Patrick Dever | Westminster | +12.3% | PB | |
| 16 | Bob Norr | Frostburg State | -0.2% | ||
| 17 | Justin Zimmerman | Frostburg State | – | ||
